The Weekly Mind Reader: Clinical Trial Disparities

by Staff Writer
June 16, 2023 at 9:05 AM UTC

minor ear anomalies are more common in people with depressive order.

At the American Society of Clinical Psychopharmacology (ASCP) annual meeting held earlier this month, a panel of distinguished psychiatrists presented data and statistics related to disparities in healthcare. As part of their discussion, they focused on clinical trials in a piece just published in The Journal of Clinical Psychiatry. 

Clinical Trial Disparities

Racial and ethnic disparities in clinical trials mirror persistent issues within the US healthcare system itself. Lack of diversity in both trial participants and the researchers conducting the studies can skew findings. Medical questions viewed through a narrow lens often return results that have limited value.

For instance, genetic data’s predictive power for complex traits is significantly lower in populations of non-White European descent. This makes it a challenge to accurately assess health information needed to make crucial clinical decisions. Medication efficacy, safety profiles, and pharmacokinetics can also vary between different racial and ethnic groups. 

Shockingly, despite this knowledge, most FDA-approved drugs are still tested primarily on White participants. It’s impossible to evaluate potential differences in safety, efficacy, dosing, and other factors for various other racial and ethnic groups. The consequences of this biased approach were evident in recent trials evaluating cancer treatments. The increased risk of toxicity in Black participants went unnoticed due to their low representation in the subject groups.

Data from 2018 reveals that only 41 percent of reported clinical trials included race and ethnicity data from all five commonly reported groups. There was an overrepresentation of White participants and underrepresentation of Hispanic/Latinx, Asian, and American Indian/Alaska Native participants. Similar disparities exist in psychiatric and depression treatment trials, with underrepresentation of Asian, Native Hawaiian, Pacific Islander, and other historically marginalized populations.

However, while underrepresented in most trials, Black individuals are overrepresented in trials using the FDA’s exceptions from the informed consent (EFIC) process. This often yielded ineffective experimental treatments and creates mistrust of science in that community. 

Proposed Solutions

The FDA has attempted to address lack of representation. Recently they released draft guidance recommending sponsors submit diversity plans with an eye toward enrolling participants from racial and ethnic populations in proportions representative of the US population. But this doesn’t solve the persistent disparities that persist within the healthcare workforce itself. 

There are fewer Asian, Black, and Hispanic psychologists and psychiatrists compared to the general population. Furthermore, grant applications from Black investigators face lower discussion and funding rates compared to their White counterparts. Implicit biases also seem to hinder discussions about clinical trials with BIPOC patients.

The ASCP panel proposed focusing on community engagement as a way to recruit marginalized populations into clinical trials. That said, they recognize the need for even more comprehensive efforts to enhance diversity at all levels of clinical research – and healthcare in general.

MORE PSYCHIATRY AND NEUROLOGY NEWS THIS WEEK

  • Weight loss may help improve the psychiatric symptoms associated with obstructive sleep disorder.
  • Even a slight vitamin C deficiency can cause psychiatric disturbances such as apathy, fatigue, and low mood.
  • Financial scams are a particularly onerous form of elder abuse. Clinicians can help prevent older  patients from getting conned out of their life savings. 
  • Although fluoxetine is safe in children for treating depression, a new case report is a good reminder to proceed with caution. Besides causing symptoms including insomnia, nausea, and headache, a too-large dose of the drug is associated with the rare but serious side effect of urinary retention. 
  • A new JCP 5 Minute Pearls video discusses the metamorphic revolution happening in psychiatry, led by psychedelic therapy and MDMA. Scott Aaronson, MD explains. 
  • Our Tweet of the Week showcases a new podcast by a National Alliance on Mental Illness (NAMI) ambassador describing her harrowing experience with second trimester mania. It underscores the urgent need for the emerging speciality of reproductive psychiatry. Please note: if you sign up for the upcoming CME meeting detailed below, CME Institute will donate all registration fee proceeds to NAMI.

NEW AT CME INSTITUTE

Save 50% on the Emerging Perspectives in Psychiatry live CME meeting with code WMR50! Join us in New York City on June 24 to earn free 5.0 CME credits and learn from leading experts on schizophrenia, ADHD, addiction, MDD, and PPD.

Commentary

Learning by Doing: Can Our Collective Experiences as Clinicians Improve Mental Health Care?

Drs Rush and Tramontin discuss how simple outcomes, often patient reported, could facilitate evidence-based decision making by clinicians, administrators, and payors and provide the foundation for a learning health care system.

A. John Rush and others

Letter to the Editor

Psychiatric History of Presenting Illness Mnemonic

In this letter to the editor, the author presents a mnemonic created to help clinicians obtain a psychiatric history.

Abdulsamad A. Aljeshi